Meaning: This quote is from a review by sports columnist Bernie Lincicome, who wrote it about the 1996 film "The Fan," which stars Robert De Niro as an obsessive fan who becomes dangerously fixated on a baseball player. The quote reflects Lincicome's skepticism about the premise of the movie, questioning the plausibility of someone caring so deeply about a baseball player to the extent portrayed in the film.

Lincicome's statement touches on several themes that are relevant to the movie and to the broader cultural significance of sports and celebrity. The quote raises questions about the nature of celebrity worship, the intensity of fandom, and the potential dangers of obsession. Additionally, it points to the larger societal fascination with celebrity culture and the sometimes extreme behaviors it can inspire.

The Fan explores the dark side of sports fandom and the psychological complexities of obsession, as De Niro's character becomes increasingly unhinged in his fixation on the baseball player. The film delves into the blurred lines between admiration and unhealthy fixation, shedding light on the potentially toxic consequences of unchecked idolization.

Lincicome's skepticism about the plausibility of such extreme fandom underscores the larger cultural debate about the boundaries of admiration and the potential for it to veer into dangerous territory. In a society where celebrities, including athletes, are often elevated to near-mythical status, The Fan serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of unchecked hero-worship.

The quote also touches on the recurring theme in De Niro's career of portraying characters with obsessive tendencies. From his iconic role in "Taxi Driver" to his portrayal of a stalker in "Cape Fear," De Niro has often explored the darker aspects of human behavior, and The Fan is no exception. His performance in the film brings to life the unsettling reality of unchecked obsession and the lengths to which it can drive a person.

In the broader context of sports culture, Lincicome's quote raises questions about the significance of athletes in society and the intense emotional investment that fans can have in their favorite players. The devotion and passion of sports fans are a defining aspect of the sports industry, with athletes often attaining celebrity status and garnering immense followings.

The quote also prompts reflection on the power dynamics inherent in the relationship between fans and athletes. It calls into question the extent to which fans should idolize and invest themselves in the lives of athletes, as well as the responsibility of athletes to manage the expectations and emotions of their supporters.

Overall, Lincicome's quote encapsulates the skepticism and critical examination of the themes and premise of The Fan, while also touching on broader societal attitudes towards celebrity, fandom, and the potential consequences of unchecked obsession. It serves as a thought-provoking commentary on the complexities of sports culture and the impact of celebrity worship in modern society.