Meaning: The quote by John Lithgow speaks to the idea that even the darkest or most somber musicals can leave audiences feeling uplifted and filled with music. Lithgow, a renowned actor known for his work in film, television, and theater, is highlighting the powerful impact of musical theater in evoking strong emotions and leaving a lasting impression on the audience. In this analysis, we will explore the significance of this quote and delve into the themes of exuberance and emotional depth in hit musicals such as Cabaret, West Side Story, and Carousel.

The mention of "darkest hit musicals" immediately draws attention to the juxtaposition of darkness and popularity in musical theater. While many successful musicals are known for their uplifting and joyous themes, Lithgow's assertion that even darker musicals can be exuberant experiences challenges traditional perceptions of the genre. This suggests that the emotional complexity and depth found in these productions contribute to their impact and ability to resonate with audiences.

First, let's consider the musical "Cabaret." Set in the early 1930s during the rise of the Nazi regime in Germany, "Cabaret" delves into themes of political turmoil, societal decadence, and the looming threat of authoritarianism. Despite its dark subject matter, the musical is known for its exuberant and captivating performances, as well as its iconic music and choreography. The juxtaposition of the vivacious and alluring atmosphere of the Kit Kat Klub with the underlying tension and uncertainty in the characters' lives creates a compelling and emotionally rich experience for the audience.

Similarly, "West Side Story" explores themes of love, prejudice, and gang violence in the context of a modern retelling of Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet." The musical's high-energy dance numbers and memorable songs convey a sense of exuberance, even as the narrative delves into the tragic consequences of social conflict and intolerance. The juxtaposition of the characters' vibrant expressions of love and passion with the harsh realities of urban violence and prejudice underscores the emotional depth of the musical.

Moving on to "Carousel," this classic musical by Rodgers and Hammerstein addresses themes of love, redemption, and the complexities of human relationships. Set against a backdrop of a seaside town in Maine, "Carousel" grapples with issues of regret, second chances, and the cyclical nature of life. The musical's iconic score, including songs like "You'll Never Walk Alone" and "If I Loved You," reflects a sense of exuberance and emotional resonance that lingers with audiences long after the final curtain falls.

Lithgow's assertion that these dark musicals leave audiences "filled with music" speaks to the enduring impact of the emotional journey experienced during the performances. The music in these musicals serves as a powerful force that elevates the storytelling and allows the audience to connect with the characters' joys, sorrows, and struggles on a deeply emotional level.

In conclusion, John Lithgow's quote sheds light on the multifaceted nature of hit musicals, particularly those with darker themes. Despite delving into complex and sometimes somber subject matter, musicals such as "Cabaret," "West Side Story," and "Carousel" captivate audiences with their exuberant experiences and leave them filled with the transformative power of music. These musicals challenge conventional perceptions of darkness in theater and demonstrate the ability of the genre to evoke profound emotions while leaving a lasting impression on those who experience them.