Meaning: This quote is from Bjorn Lomborg, a Danish author and scientist known for his work on global environmental issues. In this quote, Lomborg refers to a scathing review published in the prestigious scientific journal Nature, which criticized his work. Despite not explicitly using the word "incompetent," the review essentially questioned his competence. Lomborg mentions that he intends to respond to the criticisms by addressing them point by point on his website.

Bjorn Lomborg is best known for his controversial book "The Skeptical Environmentalist," in which he challenges widely-held beliefs about the state of the environment and argues that many environmental concerns are overstated. His work has sparked intense debate and criticism from environmentalists, scientists, and policymakers.

The review mentioned in the quote likely stems from the contentious nature of Lomborg's work. His contrarian views have earned him both acclaim and criticism. Some applaud him for challenging conventional wisdom and promoting a more cost-effective approach to environmental issues, while others accuse him of downplaying the severity of environmental problems and undermining efforts to address them.

Lomborg's decision to respond to the scathing review in Nature by publishing a detailed reply on his website reflects his commitment to engaging in debate and defending his positions. This approach allows him to directly address the specific criticisms leveled against him, providing a platform for a thorough rebuttal.

It is important to note that the quote captures the essence of intellectual discourse and the exchange of ideas within the scientific community. Disagreement and critique are fundamental to the progress of knowledge, and the ability to engage in constructive debate is a hallmark of scientific inquiry. Lomborg's response to the review exemplifies the importance of open dialogue and the willingness to engage with opposing viewpoints.

Moreover, the quote also highlights the evolving nature of scientific communication. With the advent of the internet and personal websites, scholars and scientists have the opportunity to directly engage with their audience and respond to criticisms in a timely manner. This direct interaction fosters transparency and allows for a more nuanced understanding of complex issues.

In conclusion, Bjorn Lomborg's quote encapsulates the challenges and dynamics of the scientific discourse surrounding environmental issues. It underscores the importance of rigorous debate, the need for critical engagement with opposing viewpoints, and the evolving nature of scientific communication in the digital age. By addressing the criticisms head-on and providing a detailed response, Lomborg demonstrates his commitment to intellectual integrity and the pursuit of truth within the scientific community.