Meaning: This quote by Norman MacCaig, a Scottish poet, reflects his skepticism and critical view of certain contemporary poets and their work. MacCaig expresses his belief that much of the poetry produced by these poets is "absolute baloney," suggesting that he finds their work to be lacking in substance or truth. He specifically mentions "Charles Olsens and people like that," indicating a general dissatisfaction with the poetic output of these individuals. MacCaig goes on to explain that while he initially sought to understand and engage with their poetry, he ultimately found it to be lacking in the profound impact that true poetry should have on its readers.

Norman MacCaig was known for his sharp wit and candid opinions, and this quote is a testament to his willingness to challenge the status quo and express his genuine feelings about contemporary poetry. It is important to consider the context in which MacCaig made this statement, as the world of poetry is often characterized by diverse perspectives and varying schools of thought. MacCaig's critique may have been directed at a specific movement or style of poetry that he found unappealing or lacking in artistic merit.

In the realm of poetry, the concept of "true poetry" is subjective and open to interpretation. MacCaig's assertion that certain poets and their work failed to "move" him in the way that true poetry should suggests that he values emotional and intellectual depth in the art form. For MacCaig, true poetry appears to be that which resonates on a profound level, evoking strong emotions and prompting deep contemplation.

The quote also sheds light on MacCaig's own artistic sensibilities and standards for poetry. As a respected poet himself, he likely held his own work and that of his contemporaries to high standards. His reference to "true poetry" implies that he believed in the power of poetry to convey genuine human experience and emotion, and he may have felt that the work of the poets he criticized fell short of this ideal.

It is worth noting that MacCaig's critique does not necessarily invalidate the work of the poets he mentions or others who may fall into the category of "those Charles Olsens and people like that." Poetry, like all forms of art, is subjective, and what resonates deeply with one reader may not have the same impact on another. Different poets and styles cater to diverse tastes and preferences, and the value of a poem often lies in the eye of the beholder.

In conclusion, Norman MacCaig's quote serves as a thought-provoking commentary on the nature of contemporary poetry and the standards by which it should be judged. It reflects his personal views on what constitutes "true poetry" and his willingness to challenge and critique the work of his peers. While his words may be seen as controversial or dismissive by some, they offer insight into his artistic values and expectations for the art form. Ultimately, MacCaig's quote encourages readers to consider the essence of poetry and the impact it has on individuals, prompting a deeper exploration of the qualities that define meaningful and resonant verse.