Meaning: The quote "Would that well-thinking people should be replaced by thinking ones" by Natalie Barney is a thought-provoking reflection on the distinction between well-thinking and thinking individuals. Natalie Clifford Barney (1876-1972) was an American playwright, poet, and novelist who spent most of her life in Paris. She was known for her wit, intellect, and her influential literary salon that attracted many prominent writers and artists of her time. This quote encapsulates Barney's belief in the value of critical thinking and intellectual engagement.

Barney's quote seems to suggest a preference for individuals who think deeply and critically, rather than merely possessing good intentions or being "well-thinking." The distinction between being "well-thinking" and "thinking" can be interpreted in various ways. "Well-thinking" people may be those who have good intentions, but perhaps do not engage in critical analysis or independent thought. On the other hand, "thinking" individuals are likely to be those who actively question, analyze, and reflect on their beliefs and actions.

In the context of Barney's life and work, this quote could be seen as a call for intellectual rigor and a rejection of complacency. Barney's own life was marked by her intellectual pursuits and her championing of individual freedom and self-expression. She defied social norms of her time, openly embracing her identity as a lesbian and challenging conventional gender roles. Her literary salon provided a space for open dialogue and the exchange of ideas, reflecting her commitment to intellectual discourse and the exploration of diverse perspectives.

Barney's quote also resonates with broader philosophical and societal implications. In a world where superficial judgments and intentions often take precedence over critical thinking and analysis, her words serve as a reminder of the importance of intellectual curiosity and the pursuit of knowledge. The quote may also be interpreted as a critique of blind conformity and the need for individuals to think independently, question assumptions, and engage in meaningful dialogue.

Furthermore, the quote raises questions about the nature of "well-thinking" and the potential limitations of good intentions. While good intentions are undoubtedly valuable, they may not always lead to thoughtful action or meaningful change without critical reflection and analysis. Barney's call for "thinking ones" suggests a desire for individuals who not only mean well but also actively engage with complex issues and actively seek to understand and address them.

In conclusion, Natalie Barney's quote "Would that well-thinking people should be replaced by thinking ones" offers a compelling reflection on the value of critical thinking and intellectual engagement. It encourages individuals to move beyond mere good intentions and embrace the pursuit of knowledge, independent thought, and meaningful discourse. In today's world, Barney's words continue to resonate as a reminder of the enduring importance of thoughtful, critical engagement with the complexities of life and society.