Meaning: This quote by Phyllis McGinley, an American author and poet, reflects on the challenges of engaging in argument and debate with individuals who are closed-minded and resistant to reason. The quote captures the frustration and exasperation that can arise when trying to present facts and engage in rational discourse with someone who is unwilling to consider alternative viewpoints or evidence. Let's delve deeper into the meaning and significance of this quote.

McGinley's use of the word "blithe" in the opening line suggests a sense of carefree or cheerful readiness to engage in argument. Despite being armed with facts and maintaining a merry disposition, she expresses a hope for protection from encountering a particular type of adversary – the fool. In this context, the fool represents someone who is obstinately resistant to reason and rational argumentation. The use of the word "fool" in this quote conveys a sense of exasperation and frustration at the prospect of encountering such individuals in a debate or argument.

The line "Whose mind to him a kingdom is" highlights the self-imposed mental isolation of the fool, who sees their own mind as a domain over which they exert absolute control. This portrayal suggests that the fool is unwilling to entertain alternative perspectives or allow reason to govern their thoughts and beliefs. Instead, their mind becomes a closed kingdom where reason holds no sway, and they are unwilling to consider viewpoints that challenge their own.

The next line, "Where reason lacks dominion," further emphasizes the resistance to rationality and logic that characterizes the fool. Despite being presented with facts and evidence, the fool remains impervious to the influence of reason, creating an environment where rational discourse and constructive argumentation are ineffective.

The final two lines of the quote serve as a poignant commentary on the mindset of the fool. The fool is depicted as someone who conflates conviction with prejudice and opinion with prejudice. This suggests a refusal to acknowledge the distinction between deeply held beliefs based on evidence and reasoned consideration, and prejudiced or biased viewpoints rooted in unfounded assumptions or preconceptions. The fool's inability to discern between conviction and prejudice, as well as between opinion and prejudice, underscores their unwillingness to engage in genuine, open-minded dialogue.

Phyllis McGinley's quote encapsulates the frustration and exasperation that can arise when attempting to engage in meaningful discourse with individuals who are entrenched in their own closed-mindedness. It serves as a reminder of the challenges inherent in navigating conversations with those who are resistant to reason and impervious to evidence. The quote also highlights the importance of fostering open-mindedness, critical thinking, and a willingness to consider alternative perspectives in constructive dialogue and debate.

In conclusion, Phyllis McGinley's quote offers a poignant reflection on the challenges of engaging in argument and debate with individuals who are closed-minded and resistant to reason. Through vivid language and evocative imagery, the quote captures the frustration and exasperation that can arise when attempting to present facts and engage in rational discourse with individuals who are unwilling to consider alternative viewpoints or evidence. It serves as a reminder of the importance of open-mindedness, critical thinking, and a willingness to engage in constructive dialogue and debate.