Meaning: This quote by Michael Nyman, a renowned composer, reflects his frustration and confusion over being asked to compose music in a style that did not match the thematic context of the film. Nyman is questioning the decision-making process that led to him being tasked with creating a score that seemed incongruent with the film's narrative and setting. This quote sheds light on the challenges and complexities that composers often face when working on film projects.

In this quote, Nyman expresses his perplexity about being approached to compose music for a film that seemingly had "nothing to do with American vernacular." This suggests that the film's subject matter or setting did not align with the style of music he was asked to create. It implies a disconnect between the intended ambiance of the film and the musical direction he was given. Nyman's remark alludes to the importance of a cohesive and harmonious relationship between the musical score and the visual storytelling of a film.

Additionally, Nyman hints at the existence of "inherent problems" with the score that could have been addressed through remixing. This suggests that there were underlying issues within the original composition that required adjustments or refinements. However, despite the potential for remedying these issues, Nyman questions the rationale behind the specific approach he was asked to take in reworking the score. His inquiry reflects a desire for clarity and understanding regarding the decision-making process that guided the creative direction of the project.

Michael Nyman is known for his distinctive minimalist style, characterized by repetitive patterns and a focus on melody. His work often exhibits a blend of classical and contemporary elements, making him a prominent figure in the world of film scoring. Nyman's compositions have graced numerous acclaimed films, including collaborations with director Peter Greenaway on iconic works such as "The Draughtsman's Contract" and "The Cook, the Thief, His Wife & Her Lover."

The quote reflects the intricate dynamics involved in the collaboration between composers and filmmakers. It underscores the significance of aligning the musical elements with the thematic essence and cultural context of a film. Nyman's rhetorical questions convey a sense of bewilderment, as he grapples with the mismatch between the creative choices made and the nature of the film itself.

This quote also offers insight into the challenges faced by composers in navigating artistic decisions within the collaborative framework of filmmaking. It highlights the complexities of interpreting a director's vision while staying true to one's artistic sensibilities. The tension between creative autonomy and aligning with the director's vision is a recurring theme in the world of film composition.

In conclusion, Michael Nyman's quote encapsulates his contemplation on the creative process and decision-making dynamics surrounding film scoring. It serves as a poignant reflection on the complexities and nuances inherent in the collaboration between composers and filmmakers. Nyman's candid expression of perplexity underscores the intricacies involved in crafting a musical score that resonates authentically with the thematic essence of a film.