Meaning: This quote by Frederik Pohl, a renowned science fiction writer, criticizes the practice of authors relying solely on computer programs and superficial research to construct the worlds and technologies in their stories. Pohl suggests that such stories lack depth and authenticity, ultimately failing to engage and captivate readers. The quote underscores the importance of genuine knowledge, understanding, and imagination in crafting compelling and believable narratives.

In the realm of science fiction and fantasy literature, world-building is a crucial aspect of storytelling. Authors often create intricate and elaborate fictional worlds, complete with unique landscapes, cultures, and technologies. To accomplish this, they draw on a combination of creativity, research, and, in some cases, technological tools.

Pohl's critique of stories where the author has "known very little" highlights the significance of genuine expertise and understanding in the creative process. Rather than relying on superficial or algorithm-generated information, authors are encouraged to delve deeply into their subjects, whether it be astrophysics, biology, or engineering, in order to create rich and believable fictional worlds. This deep understanding allows for the creation of more nuanced and immersive stories that resonate with readers.

The reference to running a computer program to construct a planet speaks to the potential pitfalls of relying solely on technology to inform creative endeavors. While technology can certainly aid in research and visualization, Pohl's quote suggests that it cannot replace genuine knowledge and imagination. Simply inputting data into a program and receiving a predetermined output may result in a lack of originality and depth in the world-building process.

Moreover, Pohl's mention of looking up "specific things about rocketry and so on" emphasizes the importance of thorough and genuine research. While it is essential for authors to conduct research to ensure the accuracy and plausibility of their fictional elements, Pohl's critique implies that a cursory or shallow approach to research may lead to a lackluster and unconvincing portrayal of technical or scientific concepts.

In essence, Pohl's quote serves as a reminder to aspiring writers and creators that genuine knowledge, curiosity, and imagination are indispensable in the art of world-building and storytelling. It encourages authors to approach their craft with a sense of authenticity and depth, avoiding the temptation to rely solely on shortcuts or superficial sources of information.

In conclusion, Frederik Pohl's quote underscores the importance of genuine knowledge, understanding, and imagination in the creation of compelling fictional worlds. By critiquing the reliance on computer programs and superficial research, Pohl encourages authors to approach world-building with depth and authenticity, ultimately aiming to captivate and engage readers through rich and immersive narratives.