Meaning:
The quote "Chance doesn't mean meaningless randomness, but historical contingency. This happens rather than that, and that's the way that novelty, new things, come about." by John Polkinghorne, a physicist, encapsulates a perspective on chance and contingency that is deeply rooted in both scientific and philosophical inquiry. The quote reflects the idea that chance events are not simply arbitrary and devoid of meaning, but rather are contingent upon historical and contextual factors. In this interpretation, the concept of chance is closely tied to the emergence of novelty and new phenomena in the world.
John Polkinghorne, a physicist and theologian, is known for his work in the field of science and religion, exploring the intersections between scientific understanding and theological beliefs. His quote reflects a nuanced understanding of chance and the role it plays in the unfolding of events in the natural world.
When Polkinghorne speaks of "historical contingency," he is alluding to the idea that events are not random in a meaningless sense, but rather are shaped by the historical and contextual factors that precede them. This view aligns with the philosophical concept of determinism, which posits that events are determined by preceding factors, even if they may appear random or chance-driven on the surface.
From a scientific perspective, the concept of chance and contingency is central to fields such as evolutionary biology and quantum mechanics. In evolutionary biology, the interplay of chance events and historical contingencies shapes the process of natural selection and the emergence of new species. Similarly, in quantum mechanics, the behavior of subatomic particles is often described in terms of probabilities and chance events, highlighting the fundamental role of contingency at the quantum level.
In the realm of philosophy, the relationship between chance and historical contingency has been a topic of significant debate. Philosophers have grappled with questions about the nature of randomness, the role of causality, and the implications of chance events for human agency and free will. Polkinghorne's quote touches on these complex philosophical issues by suggesting that chance is not a purely arbitrary or meaningless force, but rather a mechanism through which novelty and new possibilities can emerge.
The idea that "This happens rather than that" speaks to the idea that chance events result in specific outcomes, shaping the course of history and the unfolding of natural processes. This perspective challenges the notion of a purely deterministic universe governed by unyielding laws, instead emphasizing the role of contingency in driving change and innovation.
Furthermore, Polkinghorne's assertion that "that's the way that novelty, new things, come about" underscores the creative potential of chance and historical contingency. In this view, chance events are not merely disruptive or chaotic, but can serve as catalysts for the emergence of new ideas, forms, and phenomena.
In conclusion, John Polkinghorne's quote offers a thought-provoking perspective on chance and historical contingency, synthesizing insights from physics, philosophy, and theology. By reframing chance as a meaningful and contingent force, Polkinghorne invites us to consider the profound implications of contingency for our understanding of the natural world and the unfolding of history. This quote encourages reflection on the dynamic interplay of chance and necessity, and the ways in which historical contingencies shape the emergence of novelty and new possibilities.