Meaning: The quote by Robert Benchley, a well-known American humorist, journalist, and actor, delves into the idea that great literature is born out of a profound emotional or spiritual disturbance within the author. Benchley suggests that for an author to produce truly remarkable work, there must be a deep-seated upheaval in their soul that serves as the driving force behind their creative expression. He humorously implies that if this internal upheaval is lacking, the author may resort to borrowing or adapting ideas from the works of others.

Benchley's quote can be interpreted in various ways, but at its core, it touches on the notion that genuine and impactful artistic creation often stems from personal experiences, emotions, and struggles. This sentiment is echoed in the belief that artists draw inspiration from their own internal turmoil, using their art as a means of processing and expressing their innermost thoughts and feelings.

The idea that great literature must spring from an upheaval in the author's soul aligns with the romanticized image of the tormented artist, whose creative brilliance is fueled by inner turmoil and existential angst. Many renowned authors and poets throughout history have been known for their tumultuous personal lives and the profound emotional depth of their works, lending credence to Benchley's assertion.

In a broader sense, Benchley's quote also speaks to the concept of artistic authenticity. It suggests that truly impactful creative works are rooted in genuine, deeply felt emotions and experiences, rather than being manufactured or borrowed from external sources. This notion underscores the importance of sincerity and originality in the creative process, emphasizing the value of personal authenticity and emotional truth in the production of great literature.

Benchley's wry humor in the latter part of the quote, where he quips that if the upheaval is not present, authors may resort to borrowing from others, adds a lighthearted touch to the profound underlying message. It playfully acknowledges the reality that not all authors may possess the same level of internal upheaval, and that creative inspiration can also be drawn from external sources, albeit with a hint of self-deprecation and jest.

It is important to note that while Benchley's quote offers a thought-provoking perspective on the nature of creative inspiration and the emotional foundations of great literature, it is ultimately a humorous and somewhat tongue-in-cheek reflection on the creative process. By infusing the quote with his trademark wit, Benchley invites readers to consider the complexities of artistic creation while also injecting a sense of levity into the discussion.

In conclusion, Robert Benchley's quote encapsulates the idea that great literature is often born out of deep internal upheaval within the author's soul. It underscores the significance of personal authenticity, emotional depth, and genuine experiences in the creative process, while also injecting a touch of humor and self-awareness. Whether taken at face value or as a playful contemplation on the nature of artistic inspiration, Benchley's quote prompts reflection on the profound connections between creativity, emotion, and the human experience.