Meaning: "The Oxford manner is, alas, indefinable; I was going to say indefensible." This quote by Robert Ross captures the elusive nature of the Oxford manner, a concept that has fascinated scholars, writers, and students for centuries. The quote suggests that the Oxford manner is difficult to articulate or justify, yet it holds a certain allure and enigma that makes it worthy of consideration and exploration.

The term "Oxford manner" refers to the distinctive style, behavior, and ethos associated with the University of Oxford and its scholarly community. Oxford, one of the oldest and most prestigious universities in the world, has a rich and complex history that has shaped its unique culture and traditions. The Oxford manner encompasses a wide range of characteristics, including intellectual rigor, academic excellence, tradition, civility, and a sense of privilege and exclusivity.

At the heart of the Oxford manner is a commitment to intellectual inquiry and the pursuit of knowledge. The university's rigorous academic standards and emphasis on critical thinking have fostered a culture of intellectual curiosity and debate. The Oxford manner also reflects a deep respect for tradition and ceremony, as evidenced by the university's elaborate graduation ceremonies, formal dinners, and academic dress. This reverence for tradition contributes to the sense of timelessness and continuity that pervades the Oxford experience.

Furthermore, the Oxford manner is associated with a certain level of elitism and exclusivity. The university's long history of privilege and access has contributed to a perception of Oxford as a place reserved for the intellectual and social elite. This exclusivity, combined with the university's reputation for producing world-class scholars and leaders, has only served to enhance the mystique surrounding the Oxford manner.

Despite its many virtues, the Oxford manner is not without its critics. The quote by Robert Ross, "I was going to say indefensible," suggests that the Oxford manner may be difficult to justify or defend, perhaps due to its association with elitism, privilege, and tradition. Critics argue that the Oxford manner may perpetuate social inequality and perpetuate a sense of entitlement among its students and alumni. Additionally, some may view the Oxford manner as outdated or out of touch with modern values and priorities.

However, defenders of the Oxford manner argue that its emphasis on intellectual rigor, tradition, and academic excellence is precisely what makes Oxford a world-renowned center of learning and scholarship. They contend that the university's commitment to upholding certain standards of conduct and intellectual pursuit is essential for preserving its academic reputation and institutional integrity.

In conclusion, the quote by Robert Ross encapsulates the enigmatic and complex nature of the Oxford manner. While it may be difficult to define or justify, the Oxford manner embodies a rich tapestry of intellectual, social, and cultural elements that have contributed to the university's enduring legacy and reputation. Whether viewed with admiration or skepticism, the Oxford manner continues to fascinate and intrigue all who encounter it, making it a subject of ongoing scholarly and public interest.