Meaning: The quote you've provided is a thought-provoking statement made by Pierre Schaeffer, a French composer, known for his pioneering work in the field of musique concrète, a form of electroacoustic music. In this quote, Schaeffer raises an interesting question about the characterization of Bach's music as baroque, despite its widespread recognition as sublime within Western civilization.

The term "baroque" refers to a period in Western art music that spanned roughly from the early 17th century to the mid-18th century. It is known for its ornate and elaborate style, characterized by richly ornamented music, intricate melodies, and dramatic expression. Johann Sebastian Bach, a German composer and musician, is often considered one of the greatest composers of the Baroque period, and his music is celebrated for its complexity, emotional depth, and technical mastery.

Schaeffer's question prompts a deeper reflection on the relationship between the label "baroque" and the perceived sublimity of Bach's music. On the surface, it may seem paradoxical that music regarded as sublime is categorized under a term that historically connotes ornateness and complexity. However, this apparent paradox invites an exploration of the multifaceted nature of artistic expression and the evolving interpretations of musical styles and periods.

One way to approach this quote is to consider the historical context in which the term "baroque" was applied to Bach's music. The designation of musical periods, such as Baroque, Classical, and Romantic, often reflects broader artistic and cultural movements, as well as stylistic conventions prevalent during specific eras. While the term "baroque" originally denoted a particular historical period, its association with Bach's music has evolved to encompass a broader understanding of the diverse and intricate qualities of his compositions.

Moreover, the characterization of Bach's music as baroque does not diminish its transcendental qualities. Instead, it highlights the intricate craftsmanship and expressive depth inherent in his compositions. Bach's music transcends the limitations of any single label or categorization, encompassing a wealth of emotional, intellectual, and spiritual dimensions that resonate with audiences across time and cultures.

Schaeffer's quote also invites consideration of the subjective nature of artistic interpretation. The perception of sublimity in music is deeply personal and can vary widely among listeners. What one individual finds sublime, another may not. Therefore, the characterization of Bach's music as baroque does not detract from its potential to evoke profound emotional and spiritual experiences for those who engage with it.

In addition, the quote raises broader questions about the relationship between artistic categorization and the inherent qualities of creative works. It prompts us to reflect on the ways in which labels and classifications can both illuminate and obscure the essence of artistic expression. While the term "baroque" provides a historical and stylistic framework for understanding Bach's music, it is essential to recognize that it represents only one facet of the multifaceted richness of his compositions.

Ultimately, Schaeffer's quote serves as a catalyst for contemplating the intersection of music, history, and perception. It encourages us to embrace the complexities and contradictions inherent in artistic classification and to approach music with open-mindedness and curiosity. Through this lens, Bach's music continues to inspire awe and reverence, transcending any singular label or categorization to resonate as a timeless expression of human creativity and emotion.

In conclusion, Pierre Schaeffer's quote about the characterization of Bach's music as baroque prompts a thought-provoking exploration of the interplay between artistic categorization and the perception of sublimity in music. By delving into the historical context, the subjective nature of artistic interpretation, and the broader implications of artistic categorization, we gain a deeper appreciation for the enduring impact of Bach's music and its ability to transcend labels and classifications. Bach's music stands as a testament to the profound and multifaceted nature of artistic expression, inviting us to contemplate its sublimity with open hearts and open minds.