Meaning: The quote you've shared is by Jack Schwartz, a scientist, and it addresses the sensitive issue of speaking critically about the old Jews of Europe. The quote suggests that, aside from extremists, anyone who wishes to be taken seriously cannot publicly express negative views about this group without coming across as backward or reactionary. This quote touches on a complex and fraught topic that is deeply intertwined with historical, cultural, and social dynamics.

The phrase "old Jews of Europe" likely refers to the Jewish communities that have existed in various parts of Europe for centuries, particularly before the significant disruptions and losses experienced during the Holocaust. These communities were often deeply rooted in the cultural and social fabric of their respective countries, contributing to the diversity and richness of European society.

The quote's mention of "rabid Islamists" highlights a potential contrast in the treatment of criticism toward different religious or ethnic groups. It suggests that while certain extreme factions within Islam might be exempt from the expectation of treating the old Jews of Europe with respect, others are held to a higher standard when discussing this group.

The notion of being taken seriously in public discourse is a significant aspect of the quote. It implies that there are certain topics or groups that are shielded from criticism, and that deviating from this norm can lead to being dismissed as a reactionary or a troglodyte, a term historically used to describe people with old-fashioned or primitive views.

The quote's assertion that speaking negatively about the old Jews of Europe can make one sound like a reactionary troglodyte raises important questions about the boundaries of acceptable discourse. It touches on the complexities of discussing historically marginalized or persecuted groups, and the potential for such discussions to be perceived as insensitive or even harmful.

It is crucial to acknowledge the historical context within which this quote operates. The Jewish communities of Europe have faced centuries of discrimination, persecution, and, most notably, the horrors of the Holocaust during World War II. These experiences have deeply shaped the collective memory and identity of Jewish people, making any discussion about them a delicate and sensitive matter.

In contemporary society, discussions about minority groups, especially those with a history of persecution, are often subject to heightened sensitivity. Public figures, academics, and individuals alike are expected to navigate these discussions with care and respect, recognizing the weight of historical trauma and the ongoing impact of prejudice and discrimination.

The quote also raises broader questions about the dynamics of power and privilege in public discourse. It suggests that certain groups or topics are protected from criticism, while others are not. This asymmetry in the treatment of different groups reflects the complexities of navigating discussions about identity, history, and the legacies of oppression.

In conclusion, Jack Schwartz's quote encapsulates the intricate dynamics at play when discussing the old Jews of Europe and the challenges of navigating sensitive topics in public discourse. It highlights the complexities of addressing historically marginalized groups and the expectations placed on individuals to engage with these topics respectfully and thoughtfully. Understanding the historical context and the sensitivities involved is crucial for fostering meaningful and constructive dialogue on these important issues.