Meaning: The quote by Jonathan Shapiro, a South African cartoonist known by his pen name Zapiro, reflects on the presence of authoritarian tendencies within a new government. It suggests that while there may be individuals within the government who exhibit inclinations towards authoritarianism, the system's checks and balances serve to mitigate their influence. This quote is particularly relevant in the context of political dynamics and power structures, and it raises important considerations about the balance of power within governing bodies.

In many political systems, the concept of checks and balances is fundamental to maintaining a system of governance that prevents any one branch or individual from exerting unchecked power. This principle is often enshrined in constitutions and legal frameworks to ensure that the executive, legislative, and judicial branches of government act as restraints on each other's powers. By doing so, the system aims to prevent the concentration of power in the hands of a few and to safeguard against authoritarian tendencies.

The notion of "noises" in the quote can be interpreted as the actions or inclinations of those individuals within the government who exhibit authoritarian tendencies. These "noises" may represent their attempts to exert influence or pursue authoritarian policies. However, the quote suggests that these actions are ultimately ineffectual due to the presence of checks and balances within the system. While the tendencies may be present, their impact is limited by the institutional framework in place.

Shapiro's observation serves as a reminder of the importance of robust institutional mechanisms in preserving democratic governance. It acknowledges the potential for authoritarian inclinations to emerge within political leadership while emphasizing the role of institutional safeguards in containing and mitigating such tendencies. The quote also highlights the complexities of power dynamics within government, where individual inclinations must contend with institutional constraints.

The context in which this quote was made is significant. South Africa has experienced significant political transitions, particularly with the end of apartheid and the establishment of a democratic government. As with many nascent democracies, South Africa's political landscape has been shaped by the tensions between newfound freedoms and the legacy of authoritarian rule. Shapiro's commentary on the new government's potential for authoritarian tendencies reflects a broader discourse on the challenges of democratic consolidation and the need for vigilant oversight of political power.

In a broader global context, the quote resonates with ongoing debates about the rise of authoritarianism and its implications for democratic governance. In recent years, there has been a growing concern about the erosion of democratic norms and the concentration of power in the hands of authoritarian leaders in various parts of the world. Shapiro's observation about the presence of authoritarian tendencies within the new government serves as a cautionary note about the fragility of democratic institutions and the need for constant vigilance to protect democratic values.

The quote also prompts reflection on the role of citizens and civil society in holding governments accountable. While institutional checks and balances are crucial, active citizen engagement and a vibrant civil society are essential for ensuring that authoritarian tendencies are effectively countered. Through civic activism, free media, and independent oversight bodies, societies can contribute to the preservation of democratic governance and the protection of individual freedoms.

In conclusion, Jonathan Shapiro's quote offers a thought-provoking commentary on the presence of authoritarian tendencies within a new government and the role of checks and balances in mitigating their impact. It underscores the importance of robust institutional mechanisms and active civic engagement in safeguarding democratic governance. By acknowledging the potential for authoritarian inclinations to emerge within political leadership, the quote serves as a reminder of the ongoing challenges in upholding democratic values and the need for sustained vigilance in protecting them.