Meaning: The quote "Already old, the question Who shall die? Becomes unspoken Who is innocent?" is a poignant reflection on the nature of innocence and culpability in times of conflict and war. This quote is attributed to Karl Shapiro, an American poet known for his works that often grapple with the human experience in the context of war, love, and the passage of time.

In this specific quote, Shapiro seems to be delving into the moral and ethical ramifications of death and innocence in the midst of war. The phrase "Already old, the question Who shall die?" suggests a sense of resignation or weariness, indicating that the inevitability of death has become a familiar and accepted aspect of the human experience. This resignation is then juxtaposed with the unspoken question "Who is innocent?" which implies a deeper, more unsettling inquiry into the concept of innocence amidst the chaos and brutality of war.

Shapiro's use of language in this quote is particularly striking. The phrase "Already old" conveys a sense of weariness and resignation, as if the question of who shall die has been asked so many times that it has become worn and tired. This sets the stage for the more thought-provoking and unspoken question of innocence, which suggests a deeper moral and ethical quandary.

The juxtaposition of these two questions also highlights the shifting priorities and perspectives that can occur during times of conflict. In the face of death and destruction, the focus may initially be on the inevitability of loss and mortality. However, as the impact of war becomes more apparent, the question of innocence and culpability emerges as a crucial consideration.

Shapiro's background as a poet who served in the military during World War II adds a layer of depth and authenticity to his reflections on war and its effects on humanity. His experiences likely informed his understanding of the complexities of innocence and guilt in the context of conflict, and this quote can be seen as a distillation of those profound insights.

In a broader sense, this quote can also be interpreted as a commentary on the human condition and the universal struggle to reconcile the harsh realities of life with the innate desire for justice and innocence. It prompts contemplation on the ways in which innocence is often overshadowed or disregarded in the face of larger societal or geopolitical forces.

Overall, Karl Shapiro's quote "Already old, the question Who shall die? Becomes unspoken Who is innocent?" offers a thought-provoking exploration of the shifting dynamics of mortality and innocence in the context of war. It invites readers to consider the profound ethical and moral questions that arise during times of conflict, and serves as a reminder of the enduring significance of these themes in the human experience.