Meaning:
This quote by George Bernard Shaw, the renowned Irish playwright and critic, delves into the notion of "breeding" and its connection to behavior in a quarrel. Shaw was known for his sharp wit and insightful commentary on society, and this quote is no exception. It suggests that one's true character and upbringing are revealed in moments of conflict and tension.
When Shaw refers to "breeding," he is not alluding to one's literal ancestry or lineage, but rather to their upbringing, education, and social refinement. In Shaw's time, the concept of "good breeding" was often associated with etiquette, manners, and the ability to navigate social interactions with grace and poise. However, Shaw's interpretation of breeding goes beyond mere social decorum; he seems to be emphasizing the deeper aspects of character and integrity that are reflected in how individuals conduct themselves during a quarrel.
The choice of the word "quarrel" is significant in this context. A quarrel typically denotes a heated argument or dispute, often characterized by strong emotions and conflicting viewpoints. It is in such moments of contention that individuals may lose their composure, resort to aggression, or reveal their true nature. Shaw's assertion that the test of breeding lies in how individuals behave in a quarrel implies that their response to conflict is a crucial indicator of their moral fiber and emotional intelligence.
Shaw's perspective on this matter aligns with the broader philosophical and ethical discourse on human behavior. Throughout history, thinkers and moralists have debated the nature of virtue and the factors that shape an individual's character. The Stoic philosophers, for instance, emphasized the importance of self-control, resilience, and ethical conduct in the face of adversity. Similarly, the concept of "noblesse oblige" in aristocratic societies underscored the idea that privilege and social standing come with a responsibility to uphold moral principles and set a positive example for others.
In the context of Shaw's quote, the behavior in a quarrel becomes a litmus test for an individual's adherence to these principles. How one conducts themselves when emotions are running high and tempers are flaring reveals their ability to exercise self-restraint, empathy, and rationality – qualities that are often associated with a well-bred or cultivated person.
It is worth noting that Shaw's use of the term "man or woman" in the quote is indicative of his progressive views on gender equality and social justice. At a time when traditional gender roles and expectations were deeply entrenched, Shaw was a vocal advocate for women's rights and empowerment. By framing the concept of breeding as applicable to both men and women, he challenges the gendered norms that often dictated behavioral standards and societal expectations.
In contemporary society, Shaw's quote continues to hold relevance as we grapple with issues of civility, empathy, and conflict resolution. In a world where public discourse is often marked by polarization and hostility, the ability to engage in constructive disagreements and navigate differences with maturity and respect remains a valuable indicator of one's character.
Ultimately, George Bernard Shaw's quote serves as a reminder that true breeding, or the measure of one's character, is best revealed not in moments of ease and agreement, but in the crucible of disagreement and discord. It prompts us to reflect on our own conduct in times of conflict and to aspire to embody the qualities of empathy, composure, and integrity that define genuine breeding.