Meaning: The quote you provided is from Gene Siskel, a renowned American film critic known for his work alongside Roger Ebert on the television show "Siskel and Ebert At the Movies." Siskel's quote touches on the fundamental trust that exists between critics and their audience. He acknowledges that the most crucial aspect of a critic's credentials is the audience's belief that the critic's opinions are genuine.

In this quote, Siskel is emphasizing the importance of trust and authenticity in the relationship between a critic and their audience. Critics, like himself and Roger Ebert, rely on their audience's trust in their opinions as the basis for their credibility. Without this trust, the role of the critic becomes obsolete.

Siskel's words also highlight the vulnerability that critics face. They put their opinions out into the public sphere, open to scrutiny and criticism. However, their credibility rests on the belief that their opinions are sincere and reflective of their true thoughts. If the audience doubts the authenticity of a critic's views, their influence and impact diminish significantly.

This quote underscores the responsibility that critics have to maintain their integrity and stay true to their genuine opinions. It also speaks to the challenges that critics often face in earning and retaining the trust of their audience. In an era where opinions are abundant and easily accessible, building and maintaining credibility as a critic is an ongoing process that requires consistency, honesty, and transparency.

Furthermore, Siskel's quote can be seen as a reminder of the power dynamics at play in the realm of criticism. Critics hold a position of influence, shaping public opinion and potentially impacting the success or failure of creative works. As such, it is essential that they operate with a sense of integrity and authenticity, recognizing the weight of their words and the impact they can have on the artists and creators they critique.

In conclusion, Gene Siskel's quote encapsulates the significance of trust and authenticity in the relationship between critics and their audience. It highlights the essential role that belief in a critic's sincerity plays in establishing their credentials. Critics like Siskel and Ebert rely on this foundational trust to maintain their influence and credibility, making it imperative for them to consistently uphold their integrity and remain true to their genuine opinions.