Meaning: This quote by Rudolf Bing, a renowned musician and impresario, delves into the topic of expressing disapproval and criticism in a dignified manner. It emphasizes the idea that overt expressions of disapproval, such as booing or heckling, are vulgar and should not be tolerated. Instead, Bing suggests that a more refined and effective way to communicate disapproval is through silence, specifically by withholding applause.

Rudolf Bing's perspective on the expression of disapproval carries significant weight given his influential role in the world of music and performing arts. As the general manager of the Metropolitan Opera in New York from 1950 to 1972, Bing was responsible for overseeing countless performances and interacting with audiences, artists, and critics. Throughout his career, he likely witnessed various forms of audience behavior, including both positive and negative reactions to performances. His experiences and insights likely informed his views on the appropriate ways to express disapproval in a public setting.

Bing's assertion that expressions of disapproval are "on a level of vulgarity that cannot be tolerated" underscores the importance of maintaining a certain level of decorum and respect within artistic and cultural spaces. He suggests that overt displays of disapproval, such as booing or jeering, not only detract from the performance but also reflect poorly on the audience members themselves. By characterizing such behavior as vulgar, Bing draws a clear distinction between acceptable and unacceptable forms of audience response.

Furthermore, Bing's recommendation to "do without applause" as a means of expressing disapproval highlights the power of silence as a communicative tool. In the context of a live performance, applause serves as a visible and audible sign of approval and appreciation. By deliberately withholding applause, audience members can convey their dissatisfaction in a manner that is both noticeable and respectful. This approach aligns with the idea that sometimes the absence of a response can be more impactful than a vocal or disruptive reaction.

It is important to consider the broader implications of Bing's perspective beyond the realm of music and performing arts. His emphasis on the notion of decorum and respect in public settings resonates in various contexts, ranging from theatrical performances and cultural events to professional conferences and public gatherings. The underlying message of his quote transcends the specific domain of music and speaks to the broader concept of civil and constructive discourse.

In conclusion, Rudolf Bing's quote serves as a thought-provoking commentary on the appropriate ways to express disapproval and criticism in public settings, particularly within the context of artistic performances. His emphasis on the importance of dignified behavior and the power of silence as a form of communication offers valuable insights for audiences, performers, and event organizers alike. By encouraging a more refined and respectful approach to expressing disapproval, Bing's words continue to resonate as a reminder of the impact of audience behavior on the cultural and artistic experience.