Meaning: This quote by William Bolcom, an American composer, highlights a fundamental question that many creators, especially in the realm of opera, grapple with: what makes an opera truly worthwhile? The quote points to the immense effort and resources required to stage an opera, from composing the music to designing the production, and suggests that there must be a compelling aspect that justifies these endeavors.

Opera, as an art form, is known for its grandeur, combining music, drama, and visual spectacle to create a captivating experience for audiences. However, Bolcom's quote suggests that simply staging an opera for the sake of it may not be enough; there needs to be a distinct element that elevates the opera and makes it truly meaningful.

One interpretation of Bolcom's quote is that he is emphasizing the importance of substance in opera. Beyond the ornate costumes and elaborate sets, there should be a thematic or emotional depth that resonates with the audience. Whether through a compelling storyline, complex characters, or thought-provoking themes, the opera should offer something of substance that enriches the experience for both performers and attendees.

Another possible interpretation of the quote is that Bolcom is alluding to the need for innovation in opera. Given the rich history and tradition of the art form, creating a new opera that truly stands out requires a fresh perspective or a novel approach. This could involve experimenting with musical styles, incorporating contemporary themes, or pushing the boundaries of stage design to offer audiences a unique and memorable experience.

Furthermore, Bolcom's quote may also speak to the idea of relevance in opera. To make the considerable effort of staging an opera worthwhile, it should speak to the contemporary world and engage with issues and emotions that resonate with today's audiences. By addressing relevant themes and connecting with the experiences of modern society, opera can maintain its relevance and significance in the cultural landscape.

In essence, Bolcom's quote prompts reflection on the purpose and impact of opera as an art form. It encourages composers, librettists, directors, and performers to consider what sets a truly compelling opera apart from the rest. Whether it's through depth of content, innovation in presentation, or relevance to contemporary society, the quote underscores the idea that there should be something inherently valuable and compelling about an opera that makes the effort of its creation and staging truly worthwhile.

Ultimately, the quote serves as a reminder of the potential power and significance of opera as a form of artistic expression. It challenges those involved in the creation and production of opera to strive for excellence, to push boundaries, and to offer audiences an experience that is not only grand and beautiful but also deeply meaningful and relevant. In doing so, opera can continue to captivate and inspire audiences for generations to come.