Meaning: This quote by Gavin Bryars, a renowned composer, offers an insightful analogy for the process of creating music. By likening the act of making music to attending a university seminar where gifted specialists deliver papers to their peers, Bryars provides a unique perspective on the collaborative and intellectual nature of musical composition.

The comparison to a university seminar implies that creating music is a scholarly and intellectual pursuit, requiring the expertise and insight of specialists in the field. In this context, the "gifted specialists" represent the musicians and composers who possess a deep understanding of their craft and are capable of delivering profound musical expressions. Their "papers" can be interpreted as the compositions, performances, or interpretations they present to their "audience of their peers," which could refer to fellow musicians, critics, and discerning listeners.

Bryars' analogy also suggests that making music is a collaborative endeavor that involves engaging with other experts in the field. The idea of a seminar implies an environment where ideas are exchanged, challenges are debated, and knowledge is shared. In the realm of music, this collaborative process may involve composers working with skilled performers, producers, and engineers to bring their musical visions to life. It also speaks to the importance of drawing inspiration and feedback from fellow musicians and peers in order to refine and enhance one's musical creations.

Furthermore, the analogy highlights the importance of expertise and specialization in the creation of music. Just as a university seminar features specialists who are deeply immersed in their respective fields, the world of music is enriched by the contributions of individuals who have honed their skills and developed a profound understanding of musical theory, composition, and performance. This expertise allows musicians to deliver nuanced and impactful musical expressions, much like the "gifted specialists" delivering papers in a seminar.

Additionally, the analogy suggests that the act of making music is a form of intellectual discourse and exploration. Similar to how scholars engage in rigorous intellectual discussions and present their research in seminars, musicians engage in a dialogue through their compositions and performances. Music becomes a vehicle for expressing complex ideas, emotions, and narratives, inviting listeners to interpret and engage with the artistic content in a meaningful way.

In conclusion, Gavin Bryars' analogy offers a thought-provoking perspective on the process of making music. By comparing it to a university seminar where gifted specialists deliver papers to their peers, Bryars emphasizes the collaborative, intellectual, and specialized nature of musical composition. This quote serves as a reminder of the depth and complexity of the creative process in music, highlighting the importance of expertise, collaboration, and meaningful expression in the pursuit of artistic excellence.

I hope this information helps you understand the quote better. If you need any further assistance, feel free to ask.