Meaning: The quote by Herbert Croly, an American political philosopher and writer, touches on the evolving perception of the American Dream in relation to the concept of democracy and economic prosperity. Croly was a prominent figure in the Progressive movement, and his ideas were influential in shaping American political thought during the early 20th century.

In this quote, Croly suggests that as Americans became more aware of democratic principles and ideals, they began to question and challenge the traditional notion of the "Promised Land." The term "Promised Land" is deeply rooted in American history and culture, referring to the idealized vision of America as a land of opportunity, freedom, and prosperity. However, Croly argues that a purely economic interpretation of the Promised Land, one based solely on material wealth and guaranteed by free institutions, was no longer sufficient for the increasingly democratic-minded population.

To fully understand Croly's perspective, it's important to consider the historical context in which he was writing. The late 19th and early 20th centuries were marked by profound social, economic, and political changes in the United States. Industrialization, urbanization, and immigration transformed the country, giving rise to new challenges and opportunities. The Progressive era, characterized by efforts to address social and political problems through reform, saw a growing emphasis on democracy, equality, and social justice.

Croly's quote reflects the shifting attitudes and aspirations of Americans during this period. The "consciously democratic" mindset he refers to denotes a heightened awareness and appreciation of democratic values such as equality, participation, and the common good. As people became more attuned to these principles, they began to question whether a narrow focus on economic prosperity aligned with the broader goals of democracy.

Croly's critique of the prevailing conception of the Promised Land suggests a desire for a more inclusive and equitable vision of the American Dream. He implies that true fulfillment of the Promised Land should encompass more than just material wealth and economic security. Instead, it should reflect the principles of democracy, social progress, and the realization of individual potential.

This perspective aligns with the broader Progressive agenda, which sought to address social and economic inequality, improve working conditions, and expand opportunities for all citizens. It also reflects a deeper understanding of the complex interplay between democracy, economic prosperity, and social well-being.

In conclusion, Herbert Croly's quote captures the evolving relationship between democracy, the American Dream, and the concept of the Promised Land. It highlights a growing dissatisfaction with a narrow, materialistic interpretation of the Promised Land and a call for a more comprehensive vision that encompasses the principles of democracy and social progress. Croly's ideas continue to resonate today, serving as a reminder of the ongoing pursuit of a more inclusive and equitable society.