Meaning: This quote by composer Peter Davies highlights the importance of considering the specific context and audience when creating a musical piece. It emphasizes the idea that the style and composition of a piece should be tailored to suit the particular ensemble or performance setting for which it is intended. Davies suggests that the balance and approach to composing music can vary significantly depending on whether the piece is intended for a large ensemble, such as the Boston Pops, or for a smaller chamber music society. He acknowledges that there is no definitive answer or one-size-fits-all approach, as the requirements and nuances of each composition can differ, necessitating a flexible and adaptive mindset.

When composing for the Boston Pops, which is renowned for its popular and accessible repertoire, the emphasis may be on creating a piece that is dynamic, grand, and well-suited for a large orchestral performance. The composer may need to consider the preferences of a broad audience and the capabilities of a large ensemble, aiming to create a work that is engaging and impressive in a grand concert hall setting. The instrumentation, dynamics, and overall structure of the piece may be tailored to maximize the impact and resonance of the performance within this context.

On the other hand, when writing for a chamber music society, the focus may shift to a more intimate and refined setting. Compositions for chamber ensembles often necessitate a more nuanced and intricate approach, as the smaller group size allows for greater attention to detail and individual expression. The composer may need to consider how the piece will be experienced in a more intimate setting, where the interplay between a few musicians and the acoustics of a smaller venue can significantly impact the overall effect of the music.

The quote also alludes to the idea that the approach to composition is not fixed but rather evolves with each new piece. This notion underscores the dynamic and adaptive nature of musical creation, highlighting the need for composers to continually adapt their style and techniques to suit the specific demands of each composition. Whether it is the instrumentation, tempo, mood, or thematic elements, the composer must carefully consider how these factors will interact within the given performance context, ultimately shaping the overall impact and reception of the piece.

In essence, Peter Davies' quote encapsulates the notion that the context in which a musical piece will be performed is a crucial factor in the compositional process. It underscores the need for composers to be sensitive to the unique requirements and dynamics of different performance settings, allowing for an adaptable and contextually-aware approach to musical creation. By recognizing and embracing the diverse demands of various ensembles and performance spaces, composers can effectively tailor their compositions to resonate with and captivate their intended audiences, ultimately enriching the musical experience for performers and listeners alike.