Meaning: The quote you have provided is an observation made by the historian David Donald about Abraham Lincoln's presidency. In this quote, Donald is discussing Lincoln as a model of a particular type of presidency, one that was elected by a minority of the votes. Let's delve deeper into the context and significance of this quote.

Abraham Lincoln, the 16th President of the United States, is often revered for his leadership during the American Civil War and his role in the abolition of slavery. However, his presidency was marked by several unique features, one of which was his election by a minority of the popular vote. In the 1860 presidential election, Lincoln won the electoral college but only secured 39.8% of the popular vote, indicating that he was elected with a minority of the overall votes cast.

David Donald, a renowned historian who specialized in American history and the Civil War era, was known for his nuanced and insightful analyses of historical figures and events. In the quote you provided, Donald seems to be highlighting the paradox of Lincoln's presidency – despite being elected by a minority of the popular vote, Lincoln's tenure in office has been regarded as a model of effective and transformative leadership.

One interpretation of Donald's observation could be that he is drawing attention to the fact that a president's effectiveness and historical legacy are not solely determined by the margin of their electoral victory. Despite not having a clear majority of the popular vote, Lincoln's presidency is celebrated for its profound impact on the nation's history, particularly through his leadership during the Civil War and his efforts to preserve the Union.

Moreover, Donald's remark may also serve as a commentary on the complexities of democratic processes and the electoral system. The fact that Lincoln was able to achieve significant accomplishments and leave a lasting legacy despite not securing a majority of the popular vote speaks to the nuances and intricacies of democratic governance.

Additionally, the quote prompts consideration of the broader implications for contemporary political discourse. In the modern era, discussions about electoral legitimacy, representation, and the electoral college system continue to be relevant and contentious topics. Donald's observation about Lincoln's presidency could encourage reflection on the ways in which electoral outcomes and popular mandates intersect with the actual exercise of presidential power and the pursuit of governance objectives.

In conclusion, David Donald's quote about Abraham Lincoln's presidency as a model of a particular sort of presidency elected by a minority of the votes offers a thought-provoking perspective on the intersection of electoral dynamics, presidential leadership, and historical significance. It invites us to contemplate the complexities of democratic governance and the enduring impact of leaders who, despite not securing a majority of the popular vote, leave an indelible mark on the course of history.