Meaning: The quote you have provided is often attributed to the American composer John Eaton, who was known for his innovative and experimental approach to music composition. In this quote, Eaton expresses his belief that the true essence of music should not be measured by how "in tune" or technically proficient it is, but rather by the experience it evokes in the listener.

Eaton's perspective challenges the conventional notions of musical success and excellence, suggesting that the primary goal of music should not be to conform to technical standards or notions of perfection, but rather to convey a deeper emotional or expressive resonance. This quote encapsulates the idea that music should be about more than just meeting technical criteria; it should strive to connect with listeners on a profound and meaningful level.

Eaton's viewpoint aligns with a broader philosophical approach to music that emphasizes its emotive and communicative power. Rather than evaluating music solely based on technical precision or adherence to traditional standards, Eaton suggests that the true measure of a musical work's success lies in its ability to move and engage its audience on a deeper, more visceral level.

From a practical standpoint, Eaton's quote encourages both musicians and audiences to approach music with a more open and receptive mindset. For musicians, it serves as a reminder to prioritize the emotional and expressive elements of their craft, rather than becoming overly preoccupied with technical perfection. For audiences, it prompts a shift in focus from mere technical proficiency to a more holistic appreciation of the emotional impact and artistic intention behind the music they are experiencing.

Eaton's perspective on music also raises important questions about the nature and purpose of artistic expression. By challenging the notion of technical mastery as the ultimate goal of music, he invites us to consider the broader significance of music as a form of human expression and communication. In doing so, Eaton's quote invites us to reconsider the criteria by which we evaluate and appreciate music, and to recognize the multifaceted ways in which it can resonate with us on a personal and emotional level.

It is also worth noting that Eaton's quote carries implications beyond the realm of music, as it speaks to a larger philosophical and aesthetic debate about the nature of art and creativity. By emphasizing the experiential and emotive dimensions of music, Eaton's perspective aligns with a broader ethos that champions art for its capacity to evoke genuine human responses and emotions, rather than simply meeting technical or formalistic standards.

In conclusion, John Eaton's quote challenges us to rethink our understanding of what constitutes successful music. By prioritizing the emotional and experiential impact of music over mere technical proficiency, Eaton invites us to consider the deeper, more profound ways in which music can resonate with and move us as listeners. This perspective encourages a more open and receptive approach to music, one that values the expressive and communicative power of the art form above rigid technical standards. Ultimately, Eaton's quote prompts us to consider the transformative potential of music as a medium for emotional connection and human expression.