Meaning: This quote by Roger Ebert touches on the often-debated topic of whether a movie's quality should be judged based on its politics. Ebert, a renowned film critic, suggests that the inherent quality of a movie is not determined by its political stance, but rather by other criteria. He acknowledges that viewers may have differing opinions about a film's politics, but emphasizes that this should not be the sole factor in determining its overall merit.

One interpretation of Ebert's quote is that a movie's value should be assessed based on its artistic and storytelling qualities, rather than its political message or agenda. In other words, the technical aspects of filmmaking, such as cinematography, editing, acting, and directing, as well as the overall effectiveness of the narrative and character development, are more significant in evaluating a movie's worth. This perspective suggests that a film can be well-crafted and engaging regardless of its political leanings, and that the audience's response should be based on the film's artistry rather than its ideological stance.

Ebert's statement also implies that a movie's politics should not be dismissed or ignored, but rather considered as one of many elements that contribute to its overall impact. While a film's political content may be a point of contention for some viewers, Ebert suggests that it should be viewed as a component of the larger cinematic experience, rather than the sole determinant of its quality. This perspective encourages a more nuanced and holistic approach to evaluating films, where political themes are just one aspect among many that contribute to the overall viewing experience.

It's worth noting that Ebert's viewpoint reflects a broader debate within the film industry and among audiences about the intersection of art and politics. Some critics and viewers argue that a film's politics are inseparable from its quality, and that a movie with a strong political message can be judged based on its ideological impact. On the other hand, Ebert's perspective suggests that a film's political stance should not overshadow its artistic and storytelling merits.

In summary, Roger Ebert's quote encourages a balanced approach to evaluating movies, emphasizing that a film's quality is not solely determined by its politics. While acknowledging the significance of political themes in cinema, he suggests that a movie's artistic and narrative qualities should be the primary criteria for assessing its worth. This perspective invites viewers to consider a film's politics as part of a broader cinematic experience, rather than the defining factor in its overall quality. Ultimately, Ebert's quote prompts us to engage with films in a nuanced and multifaceted manner, appreciating the complexity of their artistic, narrative, and political dimensions.