Meaning: This quote is a thought-provoking statement made by Greg Egan, a renowned scientist and science fiction author, about the film director David Lynch and his movie "Lost Highway." In this quote, Egan expresses his admiration for David Lynch as a filmmaker while also acknowledging what he perceives as mistakes or "bad decisions" made by Lynch in the creation of "Lost Highway."

David Lynch is a highly influential and enigmatic filmmaker known for his unique and often surreal approach to storytelling and filmmaking. His body of work includes iconic films such as "Blue Velvet," "Mulholland Drive," and the cult television series "Twin Peaks." Lynch's style is characterized by its dreamlike atmosphere, complex narratives, and exploration of psychological and existential themes.

"Lost Highway" is a psychological thriller released in 1997, written and directed by David Lynch. The film follows a complex, non-linear narrative that blurs the lines between reality and hallucination, and it explores themes of identity, guilt, and the nature of reality. The story revolves around a jazz musician who becomes involved in a series of bizarre and disorienting events, leading to a surreal and unsettling journey through the character's psyche.

Greg Egan, the author of the quote, is known for his work in hard science fiction, often delving into themes related to mathematics, physics, and the nature of consciousness. His perspective on "Lost Highway" offers a unique insight into the intersection of science and art, as he brings a critical eye to the work of a celebrated filmmaker from the vantage point of a scientist and author.

In his statement, Egan's use of the phrase "I admire David Lynch so much" indicates his deep respect and appreciation for Lynch's overall body of work. Egan recognizes Lynch's impact on the world of cinema and acknowledges the director's creative prowess and influence. However, Egan also asserts that Lynch "made some bad decisions with Lost Highway," suggesting that he believes there are specific elements or choices within the film that could have been handled differently or more effectively.

It's important to note that criticism and analysis of art, including film, are subjective and multifaceted. Different viewers and critics may have varying interpretations and reactions to a particular work of art based on their individual perspectives, tastes, and experiences. Egan's critique of "Lost Highway" reflects his personal assessment of the film, informed by his background as a scientist and thinker.

The quote also raises broader questions about the nature of artistic creation and the role of experimentation and risk-taking in the creative process. Lynch's unconventional and often challenging approach to filmmaking has polarized audiences and critics throughout his career. While some may perceive certain decisions in "Lost Highway" as "bad," others may view them as bold and innovative.

In conclusion, Greg Egan's quote encapsulates a nuanced perspective on the work of David Lynch and the film "Lost Highway." It reflects the intersection of art and science, offering insight into how a prominent scientist and author assesses a renowned filmmaker's work. Egan's admiration for Lynch's overall contributions to cinema coexists with his critical appraisal of specific choices made in "Lost Highway," highlighting the complexity and subjectivity of artistic evaluation. Ultimately, this quote prompts further exploration and discussion of the intricate relationship between creativity, experimentation, and critical analysis in the realm of filmmaking and storytelling.