Meaning:
This quote by Thomas Aquinas, a prominent theologian and philosopher of the medieval period, delves into the essence of artistic creation and the criteria for evaluating the work of an artist. Aquinas, known for his influential contributions to the understanding of ethics, metaphysics, and theology, offers a thought-provoking perspective on the nature of artistry and the standards by which it should be assessed.
The central message of the quote revolves around the notion that the true measure of an artist's merit is not solely determined by the diligence or intent with which they approach their craft, but rather by the quality and excellence of the artistic output they produce. In essence, Aquinas emphasizes the intrinsic value of the artistic creation itself as the ultimate testament to an artist's skill and proficiency.
By asserting that the test of the artist does not lie in their will to work, Aquinas acknowledges that the mere act of engaging in creative endeavors does not automatically confer artistic prowess. Instead, he posits that the true test lies in the tangible results of an artist's labor – the actual work of art that is brought forth into the world. This distinction underscores the significance of the final product as the definitive expression of an artist's abilities and vision.
Furthermore, the emphasis on the "excellence of the work" as the criterion for evaluating an artist's worth underscores the importance of artistic mastery and the pursuit of aesthetic perfection. Aquinas implies that the ultimate goal of artistic endeavor should be the creation of work that embodies excellence, skill, and beauty. This notion aligns with the classical ideals of art, which prioritize technical proficiency, creativity, and the ability to evoke profound aesthetic experiences.
In contemporary context, Aquinas's words continue to resonate with artists, critics, and audiences alike. The quote serves as a reminder that the value of art extends beyond the subjective motivations or intentions of the artist, and transcends into the realm of aesthetic appreciation and cultural significance. It prompts reflection on the enduring relevance of artistic achievement and the enduring impact of works that demonstrate exceptional quality and artistry.
Moreover, Aquinas's perspective invites contemplation on the universal standards of artistic excellence and the diverse forms of creative expression. While the quote does not prescribe a specific definition of excellence, it encourages a broad and inclusive understanding of artistic merit that encompasses a wide spectrum of styles, genres, and traditions. This open-ended approach aligns with the plurality of artistic movements and the ever-evolving nature of creative practices across different cultural and historical contexts.
In conclusion, Thomas Aquinas's quote encapsulates a timeless insight into the nature of artistic accomplishment and the enduring legacy of creative endeavor. It underscores the significance of the artistic output as the ultimate testament to an artist's skill and vision, and prompts contemplation on the universal standards of excellence that transcend individual artistic pursuits. By focusing on the excellence of the work produced, Aquinas's words invite us to consider the enduring impact of art and the profound resonance of exceptional artistic achievement.