Meaning: The quote "A Royal Commission is a broody hen sitting on a china egg" by Michael Foot, a well-known British politician, encapsulates a sense of futility and ineffectiveness associated with the process of Royal Commissions. In order to fully understand the meaning behind this quote, it is important to delve into the concept of Royal Commissions, their historical significance, and their role in modern governance.

Firstly, a Royal Commission is a formal public inquiry established by the government to investigate and report on a specific issue of national importance. The term "Royal" denotes that the commission is established by the head of state, and it operates independently from the government. Royal Commissions are often tasked with conducting thorough investigations into complex and contentious matters, such as public policy, social issues, or legal reforms.

The analogy of a "broody hen sitting on a china egg" suggests a sense of precariousness and fragility. A broody hen refers to a bird that is incubating eggs with the intention of hatching them, while a china egg is delicate and easily breakable. In this context, Foot's quote implies that a Royal Commission may exert significant effort and attention on a matter that is ultimately fragile and may not yield substantial results.

There are several interpretations of this quote. One interpretation is that Royal Commissions may be perceived as investing significant resources and time into inquiries that do not result in tangible outcomes or meaningful change. The process of conducting a Royal Commission can be lengthy, complex, and resource-intensive, which may lead to frustration if the outcomes are not perceived as impactful or substantial.

Furthermore, the comparison to a "china egg" may also allude to the perception that the recommendations or findings of a Royal Commission are vulnerable to being disregarded or overlooked by the government or other stakeholders. Despite the careful and thorough approach of the commission, the ultimate impact of its work may be seen as fragile or easily dismissed.

It is important to note that this quote reflects a particular viewpoint on Royal Commissions and does not encapsulate the full range of perspectives on their effectiveness. Royal Commissions have played a crucial role in shaping public policy, informing legislative changes, and addressing pressing societal issues. The thoroughness and independence of Royal Commissions can contribute to the generation of valuable insights and recommendations that inform future decision-making.

In conclusion, Michael Foot's quote "A Royal Commission is a broody hen sitting on a china egg" encapsulates a sense of skepticism and doubt regarding the effectiveness and impact of Royal Commissions. While the analogy may convey a perception of futility and fragility, it is important to recognize the vital role that Royal Commissions have played in shaping governance, policy-making, and public discourse. The quote serves as a thought-provoking commentary on the complexities and challenges associated with inquiries of national importance.