Meaning: This quote by John Gardner, the renowned novelist, humorously and cynically suggests that one should resist the temptation to hold editors in high regard. Gardner implies that editors, despite their important role in the writing and publishing process, are often flawed, ineffective, or even irrational in their work. The quote captures the frustrations and challenges that many writers face when working with editors, and it offers a somewhat sardonic view of the editorial profession.

Gardner's statement can be interpreted in various ways. On one level, it may serve as a lighthearted warning to writers not to place too much trust or reliance on editors. By characterizing editors as "incompetent or crazy," Gardner highlights the potential for editors to make mistakes, misinterpret the writer's intentions, or impose their own subjective preferences onto the work. This sentiment may resonate with writers who have experienced the frustration of having their writing altered in ways that they did not agree with or understand.

Furthermore, the quote may also reflect a broader skepticism towards authority figures in the creative process. Editors, as gatekeepers of the publishing world, hold significant power in determining which works are deemed worthy of publication and how those works are presented to the public. Gardner's words could be seen as a reminder to maintain a critical perspective on those who hold such influential positions, encouraging writers to advocate for their own creative vision and not be overly deferential to the decisions of editors.

It is important to note, however, that Gardner's quote should not be taken entirely at face value. While the humorous tone may suggest a degree of exaggeration or playful cynicism, it is also likely that Gardner himself had a complex and nuanced relationship with editing and editors. As a successful novelist, Gardner would have undoubtedly worked closely with editors throughout his career, and it is possible that this quote reflects his own personal experiences and frustrations within the publishing industry.

In reality, the relationship between writers and editors is multifaceted and can vary widely depending on the individuals involved, the nature of the work being edited, and the specific dynamics of the publishing process. While there may be instances of editorial incompetence or clashes of creative vision, there are also countless examples of editors providing invaluable guidance, support, and enhancement to a writer's work.

Ultimately, Gardner's quote serves as a thought-provoking and somewhat tongue-in-cheek commentary on the complex and often contentious relationship between writers and editors. It captures the tension and potential for conflict that can arise when creative individuals collaborate on bringing a written work to its final form. Whether one agrees or disagrees with Gardner's sentiment, the quote undoubtedly sparks conversation and reflection on the role of editors in the writing and publishing world.