Meaning: This quote by Andrew Greeley, a prominent clergyman, reflects his criticism of the leadership within the church for their failure to take the lead in the reform movement. Greeley suggests that instead of embracing change and progress, the leadership has retreated to the conservative practices of the past, hindering the church's advancement. This quote encapsulates the frustration and disappointment felt by many individuals who seek a more progressive and inclusive approach within religious institutions.

The first part of the quote, "The leadership lost its nerve," suggests a failure of courage or conviction on the part of the church leadership. It implies that instead of displaying boldness and determination in pursuing necessary reforms, the leadership has succumbed to fear or hesitation. This sentiment reflects the belief that leadership should be characterized by a willingness to confront difficult challenges and drive positive change, especially in the context of religious institutions that play a significant role in shaping societal values and attitudes.

Greeley's assertion that the leadership "pulled the plug on" the reform movement implies a deliberate and abrupt termination of efforts to bring about change within the church. This metaphor evokes the image of discontinuing something abruptly, as if turning off the power source. It suggests that the leadership actively halted the momentum of the reform movement, preventing it from progressing further. This action could be interpreted as a betrayal of the expectations and hopes of those within the church who sought meaningful and necessary changes.

The phrase "they tried and are still trying to return the church to the dry ice of the previous century and a half" conveys a sense of stagnation and regression. The reference to "dry ice" invokes an image of extreme cold and solid rigidity, suggesting a state of unyielding traditionalism. This portrayal of the church's direction as an attempt to revert to outdated and inflexible practices reinforces the idea that the leadership is resistant to the evolution and adaptation necessary for the church to remain relevant and responsive to the needs of its members and society at large.

Greeley's critique encapsulates the frustration felt by many who desire a more progressive and forward-thinking approach within religious institutions. It speaks to a broader societal conversation about the role of organized religion in contemporary life and the tension between tradition and modernity. The quote highlights the importance of leadership in guiding institutions through periods of change and the consequences of failing to meet the evolving needs and expectations of the community.

In conclusion, Andrew Greeley's quote serves as a poignant critique of the church leadership's reluctance to embrace reform and progress. It underscores the significance of courageous and forward-thinking leadership within religious institutions and speaks to the broader societal discourse on the role of tradition and modernity in shaping the future of organized religion. This quote invites reflection on the responsibilities of leadership in navigating change and the impact of such decisions on the vitality and relevance of religious institutions.