Meaning: This quote, attributed to musician Peter Hook, encapsulates the challenge that a band may face when searching for a new vocalist. The quote suggests that the band has been unsuccessful in finding a suitable vocalist and attributes this difficulty to the high standard set by the band's previous vocalists. The mention of the band being "slated" if they were to present a subpar vocalist underscores the pressure and expectations that come with finding a new member for an established group.

Peter Hook is best known as the bass player and co-founder of the influential post-punk band Joy Division, as well as the lead vocalist and bassist for the band New Order. Both of these bands are revered for their distinctive sound and the unique vocal contributions of their respective lead singers. In the context of this quote, it's evident that Hook is referring to the formidable legacy of vocalists associated with these bands, which includes Ian Curtis of Joy Division and Bernard Sumner of New Order.

The "pedigree of vocalist" that Hook mentions likely refers to the high caliber and distinctiveness of the previous vocalists' contributions to the band's sound. Ian Curtis, known for his haunting and emotive vocal delivery, played a pivotal role in shaping the sound of Joy Division. Similarly, Bernard Sumner's vocals, characterized by a more melodic and ethereal quality, became synonymous with New Order's pioneering blend of post-punk and electronic music.

The quote also alludes to the fear of facing criticism or disapproval from fans, critics, and the music industry at large. Given the iconic status of Joy Division and New Order, any new vocalist stepping into such a prominent role would undoubtedly face intense scrutiny and comparison to their predecessors. This pressure to live up to the established standard set by past vocalists could potentially deter potential candidates or make the selection process even more challenging for the band.

In the broader context of the music industry, this quote sheds light on the complexities of maintaining a band's legacy and artistic integrity while navigating personnel changes. It underscores the importance of finding a vocalist who not only possesses exceptional talent but also has the ability to honor the band's heritage while bringing a fresh perspective to the music.

Ultimately, Peter Hook's quote serves as a poignant reminder of the weighty expectations and challenges that bands face when seeking to fill a pivotal role such as that of a lead vocalist. It also highlights the enduring impact that vocalists can have on a band's identity and the difficulty of finding a suitable successor when such a crucial position becomes vacant.