Meaning: This quote by the Roman poet Horace is a satirical critique of the poetic works produced by those who lead a sedentary, uneventful existence. It suggests that individuals who live a dull and unadventurous life, symbolized by the act of being a "water drinker," are unable to create enduring and captivating poetry. The quote can be interpreted as a commentary on the necessity of lived experiences, passion, and depth of feeling in the creation of compelling and enduring art.

Horace, also known as Quintus Horatius Flaccus, was a prominent Roman poet and satirist during the reign of Emperor Augustus. His works often reflect his views on art, literature, and the human condition. In this particular quote, Horace conveys a disdain for uninspired and lackluster poetry, suggesting that only those who have experienced the full spectrum of life's joys and sorrows are capable of producing enduring and impactful literary works.

The phrase "water drinkers" can be understood metaphorically as a reference to individuals who lead an unremarkable and uneventful lifestyle, devoid of passion, excitement, or depth of experience. In the context of the quote, "water drinkers" represent those who have not indulged in the richness of life, but instead lead a mundane and unremarkable existence. This lack of depth and intensity in their lives is believed to be reflected in their creative output, particularly in the form of poetry.

The implication that "no poems can please for long or live" if written by "water drinkers" suggests that poetry created by individuals who lack lived experiences and depth of feeling will ultimately be forgettable and lack lasting impact. It implies that poetry, as a reflection of the human experience, requires a depth of emotion, passion, and a rich tapestry of life experiences in order to resonate with audiences and stand the test of time.

It is important to note that Horace's quote should be understood within the context of his broader views on art and literature. Throughout his poetic works, Horace emphasized the importance of balance, moderation, and lived experiences in the creation of art. He advocated for the incorporation of both intellectual and emotional elements in poetry, believing that a well-rounded and impactful artistic expression should reflect a deep understanding of human nature and the complexities of life.

In conclusion, Horace's quote serves as a reminder of the importance of depth, passion, and lived experiences in the creation of enduring poetry. It emphasizes the idea that art, particularly poetry, is enriched by the fullness of human experiences and emotions. By critiquing the poetry of "water drinkers," Horace challenges aspiring poets to seek out and embrace the richness of life in order to produce works that captivate and endure. Ultimately, the quote encapsulates the timeless notion that art is a reflection of life, and that a life well-lived is often the source of the most compelling and enduring creative expression.