Meaning: This quote by Edgar Howe, an American novelist and editor, addresses the concept of the underdog in various situations, particularly in competitions or conflicts. The underdog is typically perceived as the disadvantaged or less favored party in a competition or conflict, while the "upper dog" represents the more powerful or favored party. Howe's quote suggests that while the underdog often initiates the fight or competition, there are instances where the more powerful party, or the "upper dog," deserves to win.

The concept of the underdog has been a recurring theme in literature, sports, and various aspects of popular culture. It often evokes empathy and support for those who are perceived as facing overwhelming odds. Underdogs are often portrayed as individuals or groups who are underestimated or overlooked, yet display resilience, determination, and often unexpected strengths. Their victories are celebrated as triumphs over adversity and inspire others to believe in the possibility of overcoming challenges.

In the context of the quote, Howe acknowledges that the underdog often takes the initiative to challenge the status quo or the more powerful opponent. This reflects the common narrative of underdogs rising up to confront and defy the odds, often with the support and admiration of onlookers and supporters. The underdog's willingness to engage in the fight, despite the odds stacked against them, is a testament to their courage and refusal to be defined by their perceived limitations.

However, Howe's inclusion of the phrase "the upper dog deserves to win" introduces a thought-provoking twist to the conventional underdog narrative. It suggests that there are occasions when the more powerful or favored party has rightfully earned their victory. This challenges the notion that the underdog always deserves to triumph simply by virtue of their underprivileged position. It acknowledges that fairness and merit should also be considered in determining the outcome of a competition or conflict.

The quote encourages a more nuanced perspective on the dynamics of competition and conflict, reminding us that the underdog narrative should not be oversimplified or romanticized. While underdogs may embody admirable qualities such as resilience and determination, it is essential to recognize and appreciate the strengths and achievements of the more powerful party as well.

In contemporary society, the underdog narrative continues to resonate in various domains, including sports, politics, business, and entertainment. Underdog stories are often celebrated for their ability to inspire hope and perseverance, as they remind us that success is not solely determined by initial advantages or disadvantages. The quote by Howe prompts us to consider the complexities of competition and the inherent unpredictability of outcomes, challenging us to question assumptions and stereotypes.

In conclusion, Edgar Howe's quote captures the enduring appeal of the underdog narrative while also urging us to acknowledge the merit and accomplishments of the more powerful party. It invites us to reflect on the multifaceted nature of competition and the importance of recognizing both the determination of the underdog and the deserving victories of the "upper dog." By doing so, we cultivate a more balanced and insightful understanding of the dynamics at play in various contests and conflicts, both in fiction and in real life.