Meaning: The quote "At the top of the cycle you write policies for everybody, no matter how bad, and at the bottom you cancel everybody, no matter how good. It's a manic-depressive cycle" by Robert Hunter, a musician, provides a concise and evocative description of a phenomenon that can be observed in various aspects of life, from politics and economics to social dynamics and organizational behavior. This quote captures the essence of a cyclical pattern characterized by extreme swings between excessive inclusivity and harsh exclusivity, reflecting the volatile nature of human systems and decision-making processes.

The concept of writing policies for everybody at the top of the cycle can be interpreted as a period of expansive and inclusive decision-making. This phase is marked by a tendency to accommodate and account for a wide range of interests, needs, and perspectives. In the context of governance or organizational management, it may signify the proliferation of regulations, laws, or guidelines aimed at addressing diverse concerns and ensuring equity and fairness. At this stage, there is a palpable sense of openness and a commitment to embracing diversity and inclusivity.

Conversely, the quote suggests that at the bottom of the cycle, there is a drastic shift towards exclusivity and cancellation. This phase is characterized by a stark departure from the previous inclusive approach, leading to the abrupt withdrawal or annulment of previously established policies, agreements, or commitments. The act of canceling everybody, regardless of their merit or contribution, reflects a reactionary response that disregards nuance and individual worth, often resulting in unfair and indiscriminate consequences.

The comparison of this cycle to manic-depressive behavior is particularly illuminating. It draws attention to the extreme and fluctuating nature of the decision-making process, akin to the alternating mood swings experienced by individuals with bipolar disorder. The manic phase represents the period of expansive and indiscriminate inclusivity, while the depressive phase symbolizes the abrupt and indiscriminate exclusion. This analogy underscores the irrational and destabilizing impact of such cyclical patterns on the affected systems and individuals.

Moreover, the quote highlights the inherent dysfunctionality and volatility of systems characterized by these manic-depressive cycles. Such oscillations can create an environment of uncertainty, inconsistency, and mistrust, as individuals and stakeholders struggle to adapt to the rapid and drastic changes in policies and decisions. The lack of continuity and predictability undermines the stability and effectiveness of the affected systems, hindering their ability to foster sustainable growth and development.

It is important to recognize that this quote not only captures a behavioral pattern but also serves as a cautionary reflection on the potential consequences of unchecked oscillations between extreme inclusivity and exclusivity. The cyclical nature of such dynamics can perpetuate a cycle of shortsighted decision-making, leading to a lack of sustained progress and lasting impact. The failure to maintain a balanced and nuanced approach to policy-making and decision-making can exacerbate social and organizational tensions, perpetuate inequities, and undermine trust in the governing structures.

In conclusion, Robert Hunter's quote encapsulates the disruptive and dysfunctional nature of manic-depressive cycles in decision-making processes. By highlighting the oscillation between indiscriminate inclusivity and abrupt exclusion, the quote underscores the need for a more balanced, thoughtful, and sustainable approach to policy-making and governance. It serves as a reminder of the potential pitfalls of reactionary decision-making and the importance of fostering stability, consistency, and inclusivity in the pursuit of equitable and effective systems.