Meaning: The quote "If they're not temperamental, I don't want them. It's in the nature of a great artist to be that way." by Sol Hurok, a renowned impresario and manager of performing artists, encapsulates a common stereotype associated with great artists. The notion of artists being temperamental or moody has persisted throughout history and has become ingrained in popular culture. This quote suggests that a certain level of unpredictability or volatility is expected from a truly exceptional artist, and that their temperament is an inherent part of their creative genius.

Sol Hurok, who worked with some of the most celebrated musicians and dancers of the 20th century, was known for his keen understanding of talent and the performing arts industry. His statement reflects a perspective that has been perpetuated in the portrayal of artists in literature, film, and other forms of media. The idea that great artists are inherently temperamental has become a romanticized and often exaggerated stereotype, but it raises important questions about the relationship between creativity and temperament.

One interpretation of this quote is that it suggests a correlation between artistic greatness and a certain level of emotional intensity or volatility. The idea of the tortured artist, whose emotional turmoil fuels their creativity, is a recurring motif in artistic circles. Many famous artists throughout history, from Vincent van Gogh to Ludwig van Beethoven, have been characterized as temperamental or eccentric, leading to the belief that a turbulent inner world is a necessary ingredient for producing exceptional art.

However, it is essential to approach this stereotype with a critical lens. While it may be true that some artists exhibit temperament or emotional volatility, it is not a universal trait among all successful creatives. The quote by Sol Hurok perpetuates a romanticized ideal of the artist as a tormented genius, which can overshadow the diverse range of personalities and experiences within the artistic community.

Moreover, the emphasis on temperamental behavior can also overshadow the discipline, hard work, and technical skill that are fundamental to artistic achievement. While creativity and emotional expression are integral to the artistic process, they are only part of the complex tapestry that makes up an artist's identity and practice. By focusing solely on temperament, the quote runs the risk of oversimplifying the multifaceted nature of artistic excellence.

It is important to recognize that artists, like all individuals, are shaped by a combination of internal and external factors that contribute to their personalities and behaviors. While some artists may indeed exhibit temperamental traits, it is crucial to avoid generalizations and acknowledge the diversity of experiences and expressions within the artistic community. Artists come from varied backgrounds, cultures, and life experiences, and their creative output is influenced by a multitude of factors beyond temperament alone.

In conclusion, Sol Hurok's quote captures a widely held perception of artists as inherently temperamental, but it also prompts us to question and challenge this stereotype. While emotional depth and intensity may play a role in the creative process for some artists, it is essential to recognize the full spectrum of personalities and experiences within the artistic community. By embracing diversity and acknowledging the complexities of artistic expression, we can move beyond simplistic notions of temperament and celebrate the rich tapestry of creativity in all its forms.