Meaning: The quote "We influence singing but never really songwriting" by Charles King, a politician, touches upon the idea of influence and control in the creative process, specifically in the context of music. This quote suggests that while individuals or entities may have the ability to influence the performance or interpretation of a song, they cannot truly control or dictate the process of songwriting itself.

In the realm of music, songwriting is often considered a deeply personal and creative endeavor. The act of composing lyrics, melodies, and harmonies is a form of artistic expression that is intimately tied to the experiences, emotions, and perspectives of the songwriter. It is a process that often involves introspection, inspiration, and individual creativity. As such, the quote implies that while external forces may have an impact on how a song is presented or performed, they cannot fully shape the essence of the song itself.

The distinction between influencing singing and songwriting is significant. When it comes to singing, individuals or institutions may exert influence through factors such as coaching, production, marketing, and performance opportunities. Singing can be shaped and guided by external input, whether it be vocal training, stylistic direction, or the influence of producers and collaborators. However, the act of songwriting is often seen as more elusive and personal, less susceptible to external manipulation or direction.

Charles King, as a politician, may have been expressing a broader commentary on the nature of influence and control in creative endeavors. In the context of politics, the quote could be interpreted as a reflection of the limitations of power and authority when it comes to shaping the creative output of individuals. It acknowledges the boundaries of influence and the autonomy of the creative process.

From a philosophical perspective, the quote raises questions about the nature of creativity and the relationship between individual expression and external influence. It speaks to the idea that true artistic creation is often beyond the reach of external forces, and that the core essence of a song, or any creative work, remains rooted in the vision and imagination of its creator.

In the context of the music industry, the quote may also allude to the dichotomy between artistic integrity and commercial influence. While external entities such as record labels, producers, and marketers may have a significant impact on the presentation and promotion of music, the act of songwriting itself is often revered as a pure and unadulterated form of artistic expression. This delineation underscores the value placed on the authenticity and originality of songwriting, as well as the reverence for the creative process itself.

Overall, Charles King's quote "We influence singing but never really songwriting" encapsulates a profound insight into the dynamics of creative influence and the inherent autonomy of the songwriting process. It invites contemplation on the nature of artistic expression, the boundaries of influence, and the enduring power of individual creativity in the realm of music and beyond.