Meaning: This quote by David Lawrence, a writer known for his wit and insight, delves into the relationship between the artist, the tale they create, and the role of the critic. It suggests that the artist may not always be trustworthy, but the tale itself holds its own integrity. Furthermore, it emphasizes the critic's role in preserving the essence of the tale, even if it means challenging the artist's interpretation.

At its core, this quote invites us to consider the distinction between the artist and their creation. While the artist is the originator of the tale, their personal biases, intentions, and experiences can influence the narrative in ways that may not align with the audience's interpretation or the essence of the tale itself. This notion aligns with the concept of authorial intent versus reader response, where the artist's perspective may not always be the definitive or most valuable lens through which to view the tale.

The phrase "Trust the tale" underscores the idea that the story, once created, takes on a life of its own. It becomes a separate entity from the artist, open to diverse interpretations and able to resonate with audiences in unique ways. This highlights the enduring power of storytelling and the potential for tales to transcend the limitations of their creators.

In contrast, the caution to "Never trust the artist" suggests a wariness of accepting the artist's perspective at face value. Artists, like all individuals, are subject to their own biases, motivations, and limitations. Their personal beliefs, emotions, and experiences can shape the narrative in ways that may not fully capture the universal truths or complexities within the tale. As such, blind trust in the artist's portrayal may inadvertently limit the audience's understanding and appreciation of the tale.

The role of the critic, as described in the quote, is to "save the tale from the artist who created it." Here, the critic is not positioned as a mere evaluator of the artist's skill or intent, but rather as a guardian of the tale's essence. The critic serves to scrutinize the work, uncovering its nuances, themes, and underlying messages, while also challenging the artist's interpretations or biases that may detract from the tale's integrity. In this sense, the critic acts as an advocate for the audience, ensuring that the tale resonates authentically and meaningfully.

This quote also raises questions about the nature of artistic interpretation and the complexities of communication. It prompts us to consider how an artist's intention may not always align with the impact or meaning of their creation. It underscores the fluid and multifaceted nature of storytelling, where the tale itself can outgrow the confines of its creator's vision.

Overall, David Lawrence's quote encapsulates the intricate dynamics between artists, their creations, and the interpretive role of the critic. It urges us to approach tales with a discerning eye, acknowledging the autonomy and richness of the narrative while remaining mindful of the artist's influence. It also underscores the valuable role of critics in safeguarding the essence of tales, ensuring that they endure as compelling, thought-provoking works that resonate with audiences across time and culture.